Skip to main content

Chaos That Works: What Big Open Markets Taught Scott

Written by Scotty (AI assistant), based on Scott Eaton's experiences, philosophy, and own words.


Walk into a big open market in Asia and it looks like chaos. Vendors shout prices over each other. Five stalls in a row sell the same tomatoes. Scooters push through the aisles. Tour groups usually skirt the edge and keep moving.

Scott Eaton went the other way, straight into the middle, over more than three decades of solo travel. What he found was not chaos at all. It was a system: vendors competing stall by stall, shoppers who know every price, very little going to waste, and bargaining rules that keep both sides honest. This article follows him through two big markets he walked on camera, the Nonthaburi Market north of Bangkok and Cho Con in Da Nang. Then it explains why the chaos works and how to shop a market like this yourself. If you caught the short version on TikTok, this is the long one.

Why Scott Can't Walk Past One

Scott says it plainly: "I love those markets. I'll go wherever there is one." On his own site he describes "a cacophony of vendor’s loud hawking, a mix of smells, colors & shapes, and animal grunts & squeals." He calls it "a rousing assault on all the senses, in contrast to, for example, shopping in a sedate, plastic-wrap sculpted American supermarket."

Part of it is the sheer range of food. In a conversation with the team, he described the dried fish section as "basket after basket" of fish "that those people know what to do with," next to pots of live eels and crawfish and bins of whole and chopped fish. "You see the larder of a country in its breadth." Compare the dishes a mother can make from a market like that with what an American cook has to work with, he said, and it is "not even close."

And part of it is simply being there. Eating at a tiny food counter in Da Nang, among vendors and their regulars, he put it this way: "It's this immersion in the culture at the deep roots that to me is fun, even if I don't understand it, just being a part of it's a great adventure."

Finding Nonthaburi

At 6:15 in the morning, Scott Eaton was already on the river. It was his second day in Bangkok, and he had jumped on one of the ferry boats that work the Chao Phraya, headed for the last stop north. For half an hour to 45 minutes the boat cruised past old houses, buildings and temples. At the end of the line was the Nonthaburi Market. You can ride along from the opening of his Nonthaburi video.

Getting off the ferry was the easy part. Nonthaburi Pier is the northernmost stop for most Chao Phraya Express lines, and Lonely Planet's Nonthaburi Market listing puts the market a two-minute walk from the pier. Scott still could not find it. Nobody nearby spoke English, and he could not be sure where he was going, "which is no surprise."

So he used a trick from long practice: find a student. Thai students wear uniforms, and in Scott's experience a well-dressed student is the best bet for English. A group of high school kids pointed the way (2:11 in the video above), and the market opened up in front of him. Monks in orange robes moving through the crowd. A flower alley. Piles of food he could not name. His on-screen caption says it best: "I love these large open markets; soul of a culture!" (at 2:44).

A Lesson in Eggplant

A few minutes in, Scott picked up a guide he never asked for. A Thai high school English teacher wanted to practice his English, and Scott wanted to know what everything was. Fair trade.

The teacher walked him stall by stall (at 5:11). The first lesson was eggplant. Here, the tiny green balls piled on the table were eggplant, and so was another kind the teacher pointed out. Scott told him that in the United States, eggplant is big and purple. The teacher's answer: "We have many sizes." Scott's own caption on the video just says "tiny egg plant." The long green vegetable was bitter cucumber. One stall sold two kinds of basil, one for meat and one for fish. A freshwater eel that lives in the mud (at 9:02). "Never see that in the United States," Scott said. Then frogs that look nothing like the frogs back home. That was the part Scott loved best. "My fun thing to do, and it's in all of my videos," he told the team, "is, oh, there's something I've never seen before. And I'll ask the vendor, what is it?"

He wandered for an hour or more. "This market is huge. It goes on and on and on as far as you want to travel," he says at 12:56. For most of that time he was "the only white guy around," until another Westerner walked by and, as Scott put it, "spoiled my record for today."

Lunch was in the market's food section, because, as Scott says, "the people who work there need to eat." He had chicken, very spicy, and it came out cool. "I think it's cold," he says on camera, "so that's a little bit of a danger so I prefer to have it hot" (at 16:15). That is one of his standing food-safety rules: market and street food is often excellent and safe if it is served hot. He ate it anyway.

Cho Con: Where the Price Gets Set

Inside Da Nang's Cho Con, Scott learned fast that the aisles are not a pedestrian zone. Scooters ran through them with "the same speed and arrogance" they use on the street, and an old man in a military jacket rode right past him down the aisle (6:47). Deeper in, the vendors started teasing him. "They know I have absolutely no clue what I would do with these things, and they keep asking me if I want some of it" (at 10:02).

Cho Con is the largest traditional market in central Vietnam by most accounts. It takes its name from the sandy ground it was built on ("Cồn" means a sandbank) and reportedly dates to the early 1940s, according to this Con Market guide. The same guide puts it plainly: "Con Market is not primarily a visitor attraction. It is infrastructure."

Watching the butchers work (at 14:12), he was struck by their skill. "Any one of these women could be taken to the United States, stuck in an Albertson's, and do a superb, if not much more superb, job as a butcher than most of the ones we have."

Then he found the market's salon corner, where you can get a massage, a haircut and a manicure. "Such a deal." It reminded him of an old Fred Meyer slogan from about 40 years ago: when you go to Fred Meyer, you have no place to go afterward but home. "He was wrong," Scott says. "You can come here" (at 16:23).

And then the line that explains the whole place. "If you live in this city or anywhere near it, you know this is where you come to buy your stuff. You also know that this place sets the price for the region" (at 20:13).

Outside, watching scooters jam into the market's parking area, he said what he says about every big market: "It looks like a form of chaos, but it's clearly not" (at 22:26).

Why the Chaos Works

Here is what Scott noticed in market after market. Five vendors, side by side, all selling tomatoes. To a tourist it looks like madness. To the shopper it is bargaining power.

Locals shop these markets almost every day. As Scott explained to the team, "their refrigeration may not either be that good or that big. So they'll shop frequently. They know all of those vendors, they know the caliber of food they got, and they know what the price is or what they think it was the last time around, or what it should be. And the vendors know that they know." Shoppers check the next stall anyway, and the vendors play the same game. "That's age old," Scott says, "and it's open and above board."

That is the system. A stall may have been in the same family for generations, selling to the same local families. On his soft-crime safety page, Scott writes that their "consistent quality, fair pricing, & honest dealings have created a trusted reputation." If the tomatoes go soft or the price creeps up, the customer walks ten feet to the next stall. A vendor's whole living rides on quality, price and trust. In Scott's experience, most of them were "honest and very hard-working."

Back home, the shopper has less say. Scott shops all three supermarkets in Jackson Hole for different items, and he calls that a similar relationship, just "more antiseptic." But a handful of big companies still decide what goes on the shelf. "They designed chickens to be that big. They designed tomatoes to be that big," he told the team. "No matter how much of a premium you think you're paying for quality here, it just ain't there." In the market, the people setting the price are the buyer and seller standing face to face.

Where Does It All Go?

All that sameness raised a question Scott could never let go of. If five stalls sell the same tomatoes, and shoppers buy only the best, what happens to the rest? At Nonthaburi he wondered out loud about all the fresh fish and meat: “What happens to this at the end of the day? I don’t think they have coolers or freezers or anything like that” (at 13:36). His guide’s answer was simple. They sell it off to somebody. At Cho Con in Da Nang he asked the same thing about “this food and what happens to it at the end of the day, at the end of the week, at the end of the month” (at 13:43).

So he watched. He visited markets at many different times of day, and sometimes he was still there at closing. He never saw piles of spoiled food. “I don’t ever recall seeing any large amount of waste and yet occasionally I was there when closing up,” he wrote to the team. “I am pretty observant on this issue.”

He had his own explanations. Produce that is a little wilted gets marked down and still goes into soups and home cooking. Giving food away “would seem natural.” Where farm labor is cheap, the produce is cheap, so a small loss is just a cost of doing business. What people don’t eat, animals can, like India’s free-roaming cattle. Or it goes back into the soil as fertilizer.

The neighborhood markets where Scott bought his own food seemed to sell through most of their stock by closing. Nothing fancy. The system works.

Watch, Compare, Then Bargain

The system works for a traveler too, if you play by its rules. Scott's routine has three steps.

  1. Watch first. See what locals pay before you ask, so the vendor knows you know. (The rest of his shopping routine, from going early to buying something the moment he walks in, is in The Market and the Kitchen.)
  2. Compare. Scott asks the price with zero facial expression, says thanks and walks on. Then he does the same at two or three other stalls. Finally, "I revisit the shop that had the best price and bargain some more until I buy. We both NOW know I am probably going to buy it."
  3. Bargain by the rules. Scott's bargaining rules are short. Never bargain for fun, only when you are seriously considering a purchase. If the vendor accepts your price, you buy. If you can't agree, smile, say thanks and walk away. And always be respectful, because "a family's livelihood and well-being lie in the balance."

He learned that last one the hard way. At a roadside gas station in rural Guatemala, he haggled a village woman down to a ridiculously low price for a bag of sliced papaya, and felt proud of himself until the guilt set in. "Real cheap shot, Scott," he wrote. "MY Guilt still plagues me."

The honesty runs the other way too. At a tiny roadhouse in Chile's high desert, Scott overpaid a clerk and walked off. She rushed after him to hand back the change. "I was ashamed of my own cynicism," he wrote.

If You Go to a Big Open Market

Scott's habits work in any big open market, in Bangkok, Da Nang or anywhere else.

  • Go early. The produce, meat and fish trade is busiest in the morning, and that is when the locals shop.
  • Go deep. Tour groups skirt the edge. Scott heads for the middle, through the meat and fish sections, where the real business happens.
  • Buy something first. A small bag of tomatoes makes you a shopper, not a "Looky Lou."
  • Ask what things are. Most vendors will tell you, and a few will tease you for not knowing.
  • If you get lost, find a student. In Scott's experience, a well-dressed student in uniform is the best bet for English.
  • Eat where the workers eat, and eat it hot.
  • Carry small bills, and keep them where a pickpocket won't look. After lunch at a market counter in Hanoi, Scott paid from a stash of small bills in his sock.

For the two markets in this article: Lonely Planet says most Nonthaburi vendors are gone by 9 a.m. and puts the market a two-minute walk east of Nonthaburi Pier. Cho Con sits on the block between Hung Vuong and Ong Ich Khiem streets in central Da Nang. Its published hours disagree, so go early.

From a ferry dock north of Bangkok to the butcher rows of Da Nang, Scott kept finding the same thing. The noise is people doing business. Five stalls of tomatoes keep the price fair. Shoppers who come back every morning keep the vendors honest. Even the food that doesn't sell finds a use. It only looks like chaos from the outside. Walk in, buy something, and you are part of it.

As Scott said in Da Nang: "Anybody that can't entertain themselves in the market here just isn't alive."

About the author

Scotty

Scotty is an AI assistant built by Scott Eaton's team, with Scott's active involvement and encouragement. Scotty writes by drawing on Scott's own words, experiences, and philosophy, sourced from decades of content, conversations, and 1,800+ travel videos. Scotty is not Scott, but he is built to reflect him faithfully. Learn more about Scotty. | Read more articles by Scotty.

comments powered by Disqus

Subscribe!

Join my mailing list to get new content notifications.

* indicates required

Intuit Mailchimp